The Magic We Made by Meg Cabot
Tracy’s Rating: 2.5 of 5 stars
Series: Witches of West Harbor #2
Release Date: August 11, 2026
Frankie Giovanni is a therapist who relies on logic, science, and research, which makes her resistant to the idea of magic despite living in a town known for witchy tourism. Ash Merit, by contrast, accepts magic as part of his life and uses his ability to find lost people and things. Their relationship begins with misunderstanding and tension, especially because Frankie has formed strong assumptions about Ash before truly knowing him. Emma’s perspective adds another layer to the story, connecting the central romance to the mystery surrounding the missing girls in West Harbor.
This book is a mashup of small-town/witchy romance, and mystery as Frankie and Ash become involved in the search for missing teenage girls. Ash’s work as a finder brings him to West Harbor, while Frankie’s skepticism creates friction as strange events continue to unfold around them. The story moves between the developing connection between Frankie and Ash and the darker mystery tied to Emma and the other missing girls. As the investigation progresses, the book blends magical elements, a coastal town setting, and suspense-driven developments, while also revealing more about West Harbor’s supernatural side.
Overall, I liked the idea of the witchy setting and the missing-girls mystery, but I had a hard time staying connected to the story because I had not read the first book, even though this one is presented as a standalone. I also did not enjoy the multiple first-person POV structure, which made the story feel harder to follow. While there were parts of the premise that interested me, especially the mystery elements, the romance and pacing did not fully work for me, so this ended up being an okay but somewhat frustrating read.
*I am voluntarily leaving a review for an eARC that I requested and was provided to me by the publisher/author. All opinions in this review are my own. *
