Tracy’s Rating: 3/3.5 of 5 stars
Series: Say I Do, #3
Release Date: April 1, 2025
While on a much-needed getaway with his two best friends, Drake “Hurst” Kingsley, the Duke of Hurstbourne, receives an urgent message from an old and dear childhood friend, Winston Stowe. Winston is dying and asks Hurst if he would consider marrying his sister Ophelia. Hurst is a romantic and has always believed that he would know immediately when he meets the woman he should marry. So, despite his love for his friend, he tells him he cannot marry Ophelia sight unseen but promises to visit soon. A promise he intended on keeping, but one that got pushed off when he returned to London and had to deal with dire circumstances on his estate. Weeks later he receives a late-night visitor who arrives in disguise. The young “man” is actually Ophelia Stowe, and he learns the sad truth that Winston has passed away and Ophelia needs his help. A chalice from the parish has been stolen and she needs to find it before a new vicar takes over and Winston is labeled a thief. Hurst is stunned by Ophelia and in his unsettled state, he refuses to help her. But Ophelia won’t take no for an answer and eventually, Hurst agrees to help her. The more time he spends with her, the more convinced he is that she is “the one” and he offers marriage. But if he thinks marriage will tame his stubborn wife, he obviously doesn’t know her and it is clear that their road to HEA won’t be the fairy tale that Hurst always thought it would be.
When her brother Winston dies, Ophelia and her mother find out that a priceless relic has been stolen from the church’s inventory and know that her dear brother’s memory will be slandered and besmirched unless they can find it before the new vicar arrives and discovers the thief. Her housekeeper witnessed the thief leaving and saw the family crest on the carriage, but she didn’t get a good look at the man. With this clue, Ophelia and her mother go to London, hoping to find the Chalice, but she knows she will need help and despite her anger with him for not visiting her brother, Ophelia decides to ask Hurst to help her. When he refuses to go along with her plan, she is more determined than ever to find it, but Hurst isn’t as easy to manage as she assumed. She can’t deny her attraction to him or the deeper feelings that are forming, but nothing will alter her course – not even love. Will she find the chalice and restore her brother’s reputation, or will she lose everything, even the man she loves?
This installment of the “Say I do” series was the best of the bunch, but honestly, it still didn’t wow me. I loved Hurst, but I found Ophelia much harder to like. I understood her desire to protect her brother, but I thought she was too abrasive and unyielding, not to mention foolish. I also had a hard time believing they were “in love” – why? Everything he did made her angry and everything she did annoyed him – it just didn’t feel like falling in love to me. Overall, I thought the mystery was pretty good, but I found the romance lacking. This is the third and final book in the series, but it could easily be read as a standalone title.
*I am voluntarily leaving a review for an eARC that I requested and was provided to me by the publisher/author. All opinions in this review are my own. *
Flippin' Pages Book Reviews 