Barbara’s rating: 5 out of 5 Stars
Series: Bartholomew Fayre #2
Publication Date: 9/15/25
Period: Regency
Number of Pages: 272

I am a fan of this author’s acclaimed John Pickett series, and now, I am a fan of this new series, Bartholomew Fayre, that follows the three Fayre siblings to their HEA. The wonderful first book followed Penelope Fayre, the younger sister, and it is set somewhat concurrent to this one. I had pretty much given up on reading historical romances because they had become so woke and had devolved into being simply contemporary stories in period dress. So, imagine my delight when I found this series. It is a wonderful romance, historically accurate, and true to the times while still having a strong, resilient heroine.

Unlike her sister, Penelope, Caroline Fayre Cummings has known love that is true, deep, and lasting. However, her beloved husband left them after a long illness that ate up all of their savings and left Caroline and their son, Benjamin (Benjy), dependent upon her own nearly destitute family. As her bright, intelligent son rapidly approaches the age where he should be sent to school for the education gentlemen require, Caroline frets over her inability to provide that education for him. Then, she sees an advertisement for a governess and decides she can work while Benjy continues to reside with her mother. If she saves her wages, she should be able to manage her son’s education.

Edward, Lord Tarleton, has a daughter he has no idea how to handle. He’s gone through governess after governess, and they all quickly leave, either voluntarily or through his dismissal. Edward has also known deep love, and is left with two children he hardly knows and certainly has no idea how to handle. He’s advertised – yet again – for a governess of mature years and demeanor, so what is this lovely young woman doing in his study asking for the position? He has every intention of sending her packing until an unexpected interruption causes him to make a rash decision.

Watching the sweet, caring, loving Caroline burrow, little by little, under the hard, cold walls Edward had erected was a lovely experience. As I completed the last page, I let out a sigh and had a smile on my face. This was romance and HEA in the very best sense imaginable. You will adore Caroline with her spunky ‘interpretations’ of Edward’s edicts and her total, unselfish love for little Benjy. You will also love watching the cold Edward learn to love again and to discover his children as people to love rather than reminders of loss.

This is a wonderful romance that will make you smile, sniffle, sigh, and feel the warmth that a truly beautiful romance can provide. I recommend this book, this series, and this author. Happy Reading!

I voluntarily read an early copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

View all my reviews