Smoke & Cracked Mirrors by Karen Charlton

Smoke & Cracked Mirrors (York Ladies' Detective Agency Mysteries #1)Barbara’s rating: 5 of 5 Stars
Series: York Ladies’ Detective Agency Mysteries #1
Publication Date: 4/15/22
Period: WWII (1940) York, England
Number of Pages: 364

As a fan of this author’s Detective Lavender mysteries, I was itching to give her latest mystery series a try. Goodness, I’m glad I did. First, I read the short story that is the prequel to the series – The Mystery of Mad Alice Lane. There we are introduced to the protagonists and the seed is planted that they might open their own detective agency someday. Then, I came to this excellently written, richly descriptive story with multiple mysteries and the introduction of some intriguing supporting characters. Just as an aside, this author always has the best author’s notes, etc. at the back of the book – they are broad and very informative. Frankly, I usually read the notes first because it enhances my enjoyment of the story as I move through it. However, it might give you some hints about the story, so if you don’t want that, wait to read the notes – but do read them.

Jemima (Jemma) James (nee Roxby) and Roberta (Bobby) Baker have been the best of friends for most of their lives. Though Jemma married and moved away, she has now returned to York because her husband (Michael) is missing and presumed dead. Jemma was at loose ends because she couldn’t keep their repair shop up and running without Michael. Living with her brother, Inspector Gabriel Roxby of York City Police, will have to suffice until she can plot her path forward.

Bobby Baker works as a store detective at Grainger’s Department Store. It pays little, but at least it helps keep food on the table for herself and her parents. She’d leave it in a minute if something better came along. Lucky for her, it does. It comes along in the shape of two shoplifters at Grainger’s store and her friend Jemma who helps her apprehend them. What is a more logical next step than for Jemma and Bobby to start up their own agency?

Their fledgling agency’s first cases run the gamut from sleazy cheating husbands to industrial espionage, to blackmail, stolen identities, and even spies. As they move through the cases, they enlist the aid of several characters who may or may not become recurring. I liked all of them and will be happy to see them continue, but if they need to go their own way, I’m okay with that as well.

Each of the cases is excellently plotted and all of the loose ends are neatly sewn up before the end of the book. However, there is an event that puts a twist in Jemma’s knickers and I’m assuming that twist will be recurring throughout at least several more books. It will be interesting to see what happens with it in the second book – Dancing With Dusty Fossils – which releases in November of 2022.

I hope you will give this fun, exciting mystery a read and that you’ll enjoy it as much as I did. Jemma and Bobby are great characters who embody the resilience and fortitude of England during that stressful time of nightly bombings and war. I thoroughly enjoyed getting to know them and cannot wait to see where they go from here.

View all my reviews

The Willow Marsh Murders by Karen Charlton

WillowMarshMurderBarbara’s Rating: 5 of 5 Stars
Series: Detective Lavender Mysteries #6
Publication Date: 2/1/2020
Number of Pages: 354

It is official, Detective Stephen Lavender, along with Constable Ned Woods, can out sleuth Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson! What a pair. Lavender is smart, intuitive, logical, as well as well-spoken and well-dressed, while Constable Woods is more like a bull in a china shop – until it comes to dealing with people – especially the common people. Woods is a comforting, pleasant soul with the servants and they just love to talk with him. He can wheedle the best secrets out of them. Poor Lavender, despite all of his smarts, is often a bit more taciturn and abrasive – probably because he’s already five steps ahead of the rest of them.

If you read this author’s short story, The Death of Irish Nell, you’ll already know the background for this book. If you haven’t read the short story, there is plenty of background provided in this book for you to know what happened previously – and what lead, in part, to this story. In the short story, we learned that Detective Lavender did something we never thought we’d see him do – and it has been his secret and his burden to bear for the last ten years. Now, it might have come back to haunt him.

Lavender and Woods are tired. They’ve been on the road working case after case for weeks and they just want to go home to London. However, that isn’t to be because Magistrate Read of Bow Street has just sent them off to another case in the city of Ely. A woman named Mrs. Olivia Quinn has specifically asked for Lavender and Woods to come to Willow Marsh Manor to investigate a murder. As they rattle along in the coach, one of the passengers recognizes that they are Bow Street Runners. Since the man is from Ely, they begin to ask him questions about Willow Marsh Manner and its inhabitants. What they learn is a surprise – the mistress of Willow Marsh Manner is named Delamere – not Quinn. Has someone pulled a joke on Bow Street? But – that name – Delamere – sounds familiar to Lavender, but since he’s handled so many cases over the years, he can’t place it – yet.

It has been raining and flooding in the area for weeks and there is no way to reach the manor other than by boat. The manor is virtually cut off from the world – surrounded by bogs, marshes, and flooded impassable roads. When they finally manage to reach the manor it is to find that the patriarch of the most dysfunctional family you’ll ever meet has just died – of natural causes. There hasn’t been a murder – so why are they there? Ned is ready to head back to London, but Lavender thinks there is something more to the story. When Miranda Delamere tells Lavender she’d like them to investigate the attempted murder of her niece, Susanna. Lavender’s spidey senses are working overtime and he senses currents and undercurrents aplenty among this family.

There are schemes within schemes, old enemies, new enemies, old secrets and only a finite group of suspects. Can Lavender sort it all out before someone dies? Is someone targeting Lavender? Then, the body of one of the servants is found. Why was he in that location? The death was brutal, who would murder such a well-respected man so brutally?

You’ll love watching Lavender sort it all out, uncover everybody’s secrets and identify the bad buys. Can they capture them? Will some or all of them manage to escape? You’ll just have to read this excellently written, fast-paced, well-plotted, and exciting adventure to find out.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.