The Knave of Christmas by Emily Windsor
Tracy’s Rating: 4.5 of 5 stars
Series: A Lady to Suit, #4
Release Date: November 12, 2026
Alasdair Firth has just seen the ghost of the woman he loved and lost six years ago. But this is no ghost, Alasdair follows the woman and her companion to an attic room in a boarding house in St. Giles and confronts her, and learns that the woman is Grace Perkins, his lost love. When the truth of their separation comes out, he is determined to win back the woman he lost and convinces her to let him court her until twelfth night. But winning her back might not be as easy as he believes, as neither of them are the same people that fell in love all those years ago and because Grace is leaving for America on the day after twelfth night. Despite all the obstacles in his path, Alasdair is not willing to give up and finds himself falling for the new Grace, but does he love her enough to let her go?
Grace Perkins fell apart six years ago when Alasdair left for his grand tour and his letters stopped almost immediately. She was disowned by her father and sent to a reform school but ran away to London and for years believed that Alasdair had abandoned her. But now she has just learned that her father told Alasdair she was dead. She has a new life now that doesn’t include him but agrees to let him court her for her remaining time in England. With each gift he arranges for the twelve days of Christmas, her heart begins to heal and her love for Alasdair rekindled, but she is no longer the girl he loved and while spending the rest of her life with him was once her dream, she now has new dreams and she doesn’t see how Alasdair could be part of her new life.
This was a very sweet second chance romance with amazing characters and more than one laugh out loud moment. Grace and Alasdair were torn apart and only found each other again by chance, but so much has changed that love might not be enough to give them a happy ever after. The book has a lot of emotion, wonderful secondary characters, loss, creative gifts, found family, new beginnings and the love of a lifetime along with an epilogue. Overall, this was sweet, feel-good romance and I would happily recommend this title. This book is part of the ongoing A Lady to Suit series, but it could easily be read as a standalone title without any issues.
*I am voluntarily leaving a review for a DRC/ALC that I requested and was provided to me by the publisher/author. All opinions in this review are my own. *